Thule Motion 3 Rooftop Box XL Review

Introduction
The Thule Motion 3 Rooftop Box XL is a hard-shell roof cargo box designed to expand the storage capacity of cars, SUVs and crossovers. Aimed at weekend warriors, family road-trippers, outdoor enthusiasts and anyone who needs extra luggage space without sacrificing interior comfort, the Motion 3 XL is intended to make transporting skis, luggage, camping gear and bulky items safer and more organized.
This post takes a close look at what the Thule Motion 3 Rooftop Box XL offers, its key features, what customers like and dislike, and whether it’s the right choice for your next trip.
Detailed Description and Features
Design and construction: The Motion 3 XL is built from rigid, weather-resistant materials with a smooth, aerodynamic profile to help reduce wind noise and drag. The shell is designed to withstand rain, snow and UV exposure while keeping belongings dry and secure.
Capacity and interior space: As an XL model, this rooftop box provides substantially more cargo volume than standard boxes. The interior is deep and wide enough to accommodate multiple large suitcases, duffel bags or long items such as skis and snowboards (depending on their length and orientation). The wide opening and rectangular footprint make packing and organizing easier than in narrow, tapered boxes.
Access and usability: The box features dual-side opening, allowing you to load and unload from either side of the vehicle—very useful in tight parking situations. The lid opens smoothly and stays raised for hands-free loading. Internal tie-down points or straps help secure items during transit.
Mounting system: The Motion 3 XL includes a user-friendly mounting interface that fits most crossbars and roof racks. The mounting hardware is designed for quick installation and removal, and the box typically clamps securely to round, square and aerodynamic bars. A torque-indicating knob or similar mechanism helps ensure the box is tightened correctly without over-torquing.
Security: Central locking with integrated locks secures the lid and the mounting attachments. The locks are recessed to reduce the risk of tampering and usually come with keyed cylinders to lock the box to the vehicle and close the cover at the same time.
Aerodynamics and noise reduction: The shape of the Motion 3 XL is optimized to minimize drag and wind noise. While any rooftop box will affect fuel economy and create some noise, this model’s profile aims to keep both impacts lower than with bulkier, boxier designs.
Finish and styling: Thule typically offers a neutral, vehicle-friendly finish such as gloss or matte black, dark gray or anthracite. The streamlined look blends with most modern vehicles and roof racks.
Key features at a glance
– Large XL capacity suitable for family travel and long gear items.
– Dual-side opening for convenient access on either side of the vehicle.
– Robust, weather-resistant hard-shell construction.
– User-friendly mounting system compatible with most crossbars.
– Integrated central locking for security.
– Aerodynamic design intended to reduce noise and drag.
Pros and Cons Based on Customer Feedback
Pros
– Solid build quality: Many customers praise the durable construction and long-lasting materials that withstand harsh weather and repeated use.
– Spacious interior: Users appreciate the large usable volume and relatively boxy interior that makes packing simple and efficient.
– Dual-side opening: Reviewers frequently mention how convenient it is to be able to access the box from either side of the vehicle, especially in crowded parking situations.
– Ease of installation: The mounting system is often described as intuitive and secure, with many buyers able to install and remove the box without professional help.
– Low noise for its size: While not silent, the Thule Motion 3 XL is commonly reported to be quieter at highway speeds than some competing boxes of similar size.
Cons
– Price: Several customers note that the Motion 3 XL is a premium-priced box; the cost is higher than many generic rooftop boxes.
– Weight: The empty box is relatively heavy, which can make lifting it onto roof bars challenging—two people are recommended for safe installation.
– Reduced fuel economy: Like all rooftop boxes, users report a noticeable drop in mileage on long trips, especially at higher speeds.
– Size limitations for very long skis/boards: Depending on your vehicle roof length and the box’s internal length, some very long skis or snowboards may not fit without creative positioning.
– Interior organization extras: A few buyers wish for more built-in organizational features such as dedicated dividers, pockets or straps included out of the box.
Customer Feedback Summary
Overall sentiment among buyers is positive. Most customers highlight the Motion 3 XL’s premium feel, dependable sealing against weather and practical roominess for family travel. Common praise centers on build quality, the convenience of bilateral access, and a mounting system that balances security with ease of use.
Typical negative points are related to cost and handling: the box is an investment, and its weight makes rooftop handling awkward for solo travelers. Some users also point out that while the box reduces wind noise compared with older models, it is still a compromise if you’re sensitive to highway noise or want to optimize fuel economy.
Practical tips from reviewers: practice lifting and mounting with a helper the first few times; measure your longest gear against the box interior before purchase; and use soft packing or straps inside to prevent gear shifting and rattling.
Conclusion and Recommendation
The Thule Motion 3 Rooftop Box XL is a strong choice if you need substantial, reliable rooftop cargo capacity and are willing to pay a premium for proven build quality, security and ease of use. It’s particularly well suited to families, outdoor enthusiasts, and frequent travelers who regularly need to carry luggage, skis or bulky gear. If you are on a tight budget, or you rarely need large extra capacity, a smaller or less expensive box might be more appropriate.
For buyers who prioritize durability, low noise and dual-side access—and who accept the trade-offs of weight and expense—the Motion 3 XL is a worthwhile investment that will simplify packing and free up interior space on long trips.
If you’re interested in purchasing or learning more, check availability and current pricing here: https://amzn.to/47FKOSc
Product Comparison Table
| Product | Amazon Rating | Price | Buy Link |
|---|---|---|---|
| Thule Motion 3 Rooftop Box XL | 4.4/5 ⭐ | $1,079.95 | Buy on Amazon |
| SportRack Vista XL Rear Opening Cargo Box,Black | 4.4/5 ⭐ | $517.28 | Buy on Amazon |
| Thule Force 3 – Size XL – 18 cu ft – Aerodynamic roof Mounted Box – Dual-Sided Opening with Locks – Tool-Free Install – Weatherproof Design – for SUVs, Trucks, Cars, EVs and More | 4.3/5 ⭐ | $929.95 | Buy on Amazon |
| Yakima SkyBox NX XL 18 Roof Top Cargo Carrier, 18 Cubic Feet, Black – Vehicle Rooftop Hard Shell Travel Storage Box with Dual Sided Opening, SKS Locks and Universal | 4.3/5 ⭐ | $798.95 | Buy on Amazon |







